Environmental Litigation Successes

Attorneys in Keller Rohrback’s Complex Litigation Group have successfully represented individuals, class members, municipalities, and nonprofit organizations in complex and critical environmental litigation. In cases involving oil spills, mishandled hazardous waste, contaminated consumer products, and industrial pollution, Keller Rohrback works to protect human health and the environment. The firm combines its unparalleled experience in consumer protection and its deep knowledge of environmental law, making Keller Rohrback a worldwide leader in litigation to safeguard our environment and the people and animals that rely on it.

Representative Cases & Successes

City of Seattle v. Monsanto Co.
(W.D. Washington)

Monsanto Company agreed to pay $160 million to the City of Seattle to resolve the city’s claims against the giant multinational chemical company for decades of PCB contamination in the Duwamish River. Keller Rohrback had the honor of representing the City of Seattle as outside counsel to the City Attorney, Ann Davison, as Seattle navigated through Summary Judgment proceedings in the Western District of Washington before the Honorable Richard A. Jones. Monsanto, the sole manufacturer of PCBs in the United States, made and sold over 1.4 billion pounds of PCBs despite knowing they are toxic, bioaccumulate, and last effectively forever. The hard-won settlement, achieved a month before the case went to trial, allows the City to expand its efforts to protect human health and the environment.

Oregon v. Monsanto Co. 
(Or. Cir. Ct., Multnomah Cnty) 

Oregon appointed Keller Rohrback to represent the State in this landmark case seeking to hold Monsanto responsible for the harm its Polychlorinated Biphenyls (“PCBs“) have caused to Oregon’s environment, including its waters and wildlife. Keller Rohrback, together with co-counsel Stoll Berne, filed the complaint in 2018. On December 15, 2022, Monsanto agreed to pay $698 million to the State of Oregon to resolve the State’s claims.

Meeker v. Bullseye Glass Co.
(Multnomah Cnty. Cir. Ct., Oregon)

Keller Rohrback successfully negotiated a settlement with Bullseye Glass Company for contaminating a residential neighborhood in Portland, Oregon, by emitting hazardous levels of arsenic, cadmium, chromium, and other toxic materials from its glass-making facility for years. Despite using thousands of pounds a year of dangerous heavy metals, Bullseye Glass had used no pollution control technology for more than four decades. Using innovative air and soil monitoring, Keller Rohrback helped this neighborhood to protect itself and hold Bullseye accountable for the harm it caused. The settlement includes a two-year air monitoring program, the company agreeing to only operate furnaces with pollution control devices as long as they remain in operation, and monetary payments to class members, including reimbursement for air emissions-related expenses.

In re Volkswagen “Clean Diesel” Mktg., Sales Pracs., and Prods. Liab. Litig., No. 3:15-md-02672
(N.D. Cal.)
Keller Rohrback filed the first multi-Plaintiff complaint against Volkswagen on September 20, 2015, two days after the defeat device scheme came to light. Keller Rohrback represented consumers nationwide who alleged they were damaged by Volkswagen’s fraudulent use of an emissions “defeat device” in over 500,000 vehicles in the United States. Keller Rohrback Managing Partner Lynn Sarko served on the Plaintiffs’ Steering Committee for this national litigation. Lynn Sarko and partner Gretchen Freeman Cappio served on the negotiating team for the $15 billion class action settlement for 2.0-liter vehicles, the largest auto-related consumer class action in U.S. history. Keller Rohrback played a similar role in reaching and implementing similar settlements with Volkswagen and Bosch regarding approximately 100,000 3-liter vehicles.
 

James v. PacifiCorp et al., No. 20CV33885
(Or. Cir. Ct., Multnomah Cnty.)
Keller Rohrback filed a class action lawsuit against PacifiCorp and Pacific Power for the catastrophic damage to homes, businesses, schools, and entire communities caused by the power companies’ negligence and downed power lines during the devastating fires that ignited in Oregon during Labor Day weekend of 2020. In an historic verdict on June 12, 2023 a jury in Portland held PacifiCorp directly responsible for damages the class suffered from four fires: the Santiam Canyon Fire, the Echo Mountain Complex Fire, the South Obenchain Fire, and the 242 Fire. Juries have also determined that PacifiCorp must compensate named Plaintiffs for the harms they suffered to their property and possessions, as well as awards of between $3-$8.5 million dollars each to compensate those Plaintiffs for the non-economic harms they suffered. The determination of damage awards for all members of the class is ongoing.
 

In re Exxon Valdez
(D. Alaska) 

Keller Rohrback was trial counsel representing fishermen, landowners, and businesses located in Prince William Sound in their action against Exxon to recover damages caused by the Exxon Valdez oil spill. A federal jury awarded a $5 billion judgment in favor of Keller Rohrback clients. At the time, it was the largest punitive damages verdict in U.S. history. Additional claims against the pipeline owner were settled for $98 million. More than twenty-five years after the tragic spill, the Exxon Valdez spill is still considered one of the most devastating human-caused environmental disasters. In addition, Keller Rohrback Managing Partner Lynn Sarko was appointed to serve as the Administrator of the Exxon and Alaska Qualified Settlement Funds.

 

 

Andrews v. Plains All American Pipeline L.P.,
(C.D. California)

Keller Rohrback serves as Co-Lead Counsel representing fishers, property owners and others affected by the May 2015 spill from Plains All American’s Line 901 pipeline in Santa Barbara County. The oil spill contaminated pristine beaches, closed critical fishing grounds, and damaged natural resources throughout the region. Keller Rohrback sought compensation for victims of the spill for their present and future damages and to hold Plains accountable for the harm it caused to the fishers and property owners. In May 2022 a $230 million settlement was reached, awarding $184 million to the Fisher Class and $46 million to the Property Class.
 

Mapleton Groundwater Litigation
(D. Utah) 

Keller Rohrback attorneys successfully litigated a series of groundwater contamination suits against multiple international defendants accused of releasing hazardous chemicals into the watershed over six decades. The suits were brought on behalf of individuals and their families against defendants who owned a former explosives plant in Mapleton, Utah. The plaintiffs alleged that improper waste disposal caused contaminants to seep into the groundwater and that the chemicals caused property damage and non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma cancers affecting numerous residents. The matter involved complex scientific issues related to hydrogeology, chemical migration pathways, aquifer dynamics, clean-up methods, and contaminant degradation. The litigation resolved prior to trial after lengthy evidentiary hearings at which plaintiffs received favorable Daubert rulings.

Wishtoyo Foundation v. Magic Mountain LLC
(C.D. Cal) 

Keller Rohrback Attorney Daniel Mensher worked with a team of environmental lawyers on behalf of Los Angeles-based clients who successfully negotiated a groundbreaking settlement with Six Flags Magic Mountain to address its stormwater pollution discharged to the Santa Clara River. The settlement significantly reduced the amount of heavy metals and other pollutants entering the river from the amusement park by requiring the facility to install state-of-the-art technology, develop and implement a comprehensive site management plan, and fully comply with the Clean Water Act. Additional monetary payments made by Six Flags as a result of the case are being used to perform critical habitat restoration and mitigation projects along the Santa Clara River.

Resendez v. Precision Castparts Corp., No. 16-16164
(Or. Cir. Ct. Multnomah Cnty.) 
Keller Rohrback represented a class of homeowners and residents in Multnomah and Clackamas County who sought relief from Precision Castparts Corp. for the company’s heavy metal particulate air pollution that clouded their neighborhood and unreasonably interfered with their real property rights. Plaintiffs prevailed on the defendants’ motions to dismiss and for summary judgment. In May 2022, the Court granted Final Approval of a Class Action Settlement, which included a $12.5 million settlement fund for cash payments to class members, and millions of additional dollars in enhanced pollution controls at the Precision Castparts facilities in Southeast Portland.

In re Chrysler-Dodge-Jeep EcoDiesel Mktg, Sales Pracs., & Prods. Liab. Litig., MDL No. 2777
(N.D. Cal.)
From the outset, Keller Rohrback played a major role in this multidistrict litigation, representing consumers nationwide who alleged that Fiat Chrysler used an emissions defeat device in over 100,000 Ram 1500 and Jeep Grand Cherokee diesel trucks and SUVs. Keller Rohrback Managing Partner Lynn Sarko was appointed by the Court to the Plaintiffs’ Steering Committee leading this case, and Keller Rohrback attorneys took an active role in discovery and served on the negotiating team that achieved and implemented a settlement worth over $307 million. The settlement, involving both Fiat Chrysler and supplier Bosch, provided owners and lessees of the affected vehicles with substantial cash payments in addition to government-approved emissions repairs and valuable extended warranty protection.
 

Keller Rohrback wants to hear from you. Get in Touch